Wed 15 Nov 2006

There is something about a Cuban cigar’s wrapper that I find very distinct and appealing. They are generally buttery and come packed with a generous dose of chilli pepper that can be sensed from the moment the cigar is tasted before lighting—I just love that sweet spicy hot sensation.
In general, I find that even the best tobacco growers from Nicaragua, Honduras, and the Dominican Republic have a difficult time reproducing this. The Rocky Patel Sun Grown Ecuadorian wrapper, though, in my opinion, comes mightily close.

It is an absolutely well put together cigar: a good cap, even bunch, solid feel, and that wonderful semi-sweet caramel aroma of the wrapper. Cuban cigars often lack the spotless, flawless construction that these sticks have.
At first taste, I got a wonderful peppery taste. The pre-light draw revealed a bit of graphite, which I tend to associate with my favorite Cuban cigar, the PSD4. This is a cigar that I really enjoy from start to finish. It is simply perfect for those who appreciate the entire cigar smoking ritual; and I certainly do.

A good light, and the smoke yielded is very well balanced from the start: dense, rich, and with a very good dose of pepper to counter the semi sweet notes. In one word, I would classify the smoke as elegant.
The spice and pepper subside in the second third, and the smoke becomes more chewy. The semisweet caramel notes are extremely satisfying and bare a light cacao undertone. As the cigar progresses, the caramel notes increasingly become rather earthy while retaining the sweet scent that reminds me of the smell I typically associate with that of a fine pipe.

All the flavors intensify and darken past the half way point and before long a great espresso note sets in; a note that deepens in the last third and coats the taste buds with an awesome, long finish. That sun grown Ecuadorian wrapper is simply delightful.





November 16th, 2006 at 10:38 am
I’ll check this out EZ, thanks for the info…I have had average experiences with other RP lines and assumed they were another Camacho, i.e., initial market splash with no staying power…
Speaking of Camacho, recall the old Diploma robusto in the pyramid shaped box? 3-4 years ago, this was the best cigar in the United States, IMO. Sadly it has faded.
November 16th, 2006 at 1:25 pm
A well thought out and written appraisal of a good cigar.
I have tried or at least still have a few of most of Rocky Patels range as they are consistantly good quality.
The cigar under review didnt really ‘do it’ for me though.
Having read you description I will find which humidor they are in and smoke one. I tend to keep at least one of each brand I buy.
Being in the UK I have to import the cigars that the USA get in place of Cubans. They are cheap and sometimes very good, like most of the RP range.
Thanks for a great report,
ROY.R, ESSEX, UK
January 17th, 2007 at 6:30 pm
ich habe gerade meine erste rp sungrown genossen und stimme mit ihrer bewertung voll überein.viele havannas können hier nicht mehr mithalten.
January 23rd, 2007 at 2:18 pm
hello guys
if i may make a recomandation, i would recon that you try the robusto by josé marti, cuba
very smooth taste creamy and fruity good smoke
January 23rd, 2007 at 2:46 pm
Hi Valentine, I believe the Jose Marti Robusto is from Nicaragua. At 3.50 a stick, it looks great. Will have to review it…
January 30th, 2007 at 3:24 pm
EZ You are right on with the Rocky Patels. Nothing beats the experience of smoking one of these beauties. Your description is right on!
April 24th, 2007 at 1:13 pm
Great gob on the review. I strongly agree. The Sun Grown is my favorite Rocky Patel smoke next to Vintage 1990.
August 30th, 2007 at 1:20 pm
The description is good, but I guess I must not appreciate elegance. Stupid me. I didn’t realize that the first burst of painful harshness (”pepper and spice”) was intentional and desirable. The fact that the stick seemed to mellow out caused me to wonder if the smoke actually changed or if my mouth was just cauterized. Maybe I can get someone who is more into elegance to smoke the first half inch and then turn them over to me.
December 28th, 2007 at 1:35 pm
Wow Ron. You really are stupid!